Red Dead Redemption 2 offers greeting and antagonizing interactions, but GGX has not measured how every Valentine resident responds to a fixed sequence. A guaranteed number of insults before violence is [CHECK IN GAME].
The documented mechanic
RDR2.org describes NPC moods and distinct interaction options. PlayStation's hands-on coverage also emphasizes the game's conversation system. Neither source supplies a universal reaction threshold for every person in Valentine.
A fair comparison
Make a separate story-mode save outside Valentine. Record chapter, honor, bounty, time of day, platform and version.
Approach an available NPC without a weapon drawn. Use one greeting, then one antagonizing interaction, and record the response.
For a second trial, reload the starting save and greet the same NPC without antagonizing them.
Compare dialogue, movement and escalation. Keep interruptions and unavailable prompts in the log rather than discarding them.
Repeat with several NPCs; do not treat a shopkeeper and a passing pedestrian as interchangeable.
What we can conclude now
Completed trials, fight counts and response rates are [CHECK IN GAME]. This article supplies a method, not claims of having provoked an entire town. Reloading a save also may not preserve every background condition, so record differences rather than calling every change an effect of the insult.